Judy's Pizzeria Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Judy's Pizzeria, your go-to destination for exceptional pizzas and comforting Italian fare in Highland Park, IL. At Judy's, we take pride in our diverse menu, which features a tantalizing assortment of thin crust specialty pizzas. Each option, like the Judy’s Special or the Hawaiian, showcases a crispy crust topped with fresh ingredients, from savory sausage to sweet pineapple.
For those who crave variety, our appetizers do not disappoint with mouthwatering selections such as boneless chicken wings and breaded mushrooms. The inviting atmosphere is amplified by our enthusiastic staff, eager to make your dining experience extraordinary. Whether you're hosting a block party or enjoying a cozy night in, Judy's Pizzeria is well-equipped to cater your needs with our delicious offerings. Join us and taste the passion behind every dish—because at Judy's, freshness and flavor are always on the menu!
Specials - Promos
16" Thin Crust Cheese (Tuesday)
16" Thin Crust Cheese (Tuesday)
Promos
Store Menu - Promotions
Family Meal Deal
Includes 1 Pizza with unlimited toppings, 1 family size salad, and an appetizer platter. Not valid with other promotions.
Lunch Special (2 Slices Drink)
Make Your Own Pizza Kits
Makes two 12" pizzas.
Dino Nugs (6 Piece)
6 Organic Chicken Nuggets (Dinosaur Shaped)
Chicken Noodle
Classic Chicken Noodle. Includes crackers.
Store Menu - Soups
Store Menu - Appetizers
Shoestring Fries
Waffle Fries
Garlic Bread
6" loaf of French bread with a spread of butter, garlic, and parsley
Pizza Bread
Toasted garlic bread layered with sauce and cheese.
Onion Rings
Breaded Zucchinis
Breaded and fried zucchinis. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 10 pieces and a platter includes 20.
Breaded Mushrooms
Breaded and fried mushrooms. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 10 pieces and a platter includes 20.
Jalapeno Poppers
Breaded and battered chili pepper and cheese bites. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 10 pieces and a platter includes 20.
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded and fried cheese. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 5 pieces and a platter includes 10.
Chicken Strips
Breaded and fried chicken strips. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 5 pieces and a platter includes 10.
Chicken Wings
Breaded and fried spicy wings. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 5 pieces and a platter includes 10.
Boneless Chicken Wings
Boneless wings with a spicy kick. Comes with your choice of sauce.
Canned Soda
12oz
Canned Soda - 6 Pack
Gatorade
Gatorade - 6 Pack
Bottled Water
Water Bottle - 6 Pack
20oz Bottle
Apple And Eve Juice Box
Store Menu - Beverages
Store Menu - Desserts
Chocolate Chip Cookie By Sweet Thing Bake Shop
Classic Chocolate Chip homemade with love by Sweet Thing Bake Shop
Classic Brownie By Sweet Thing Bake Shop
Classic brownie homemade with love by Sweet Thing
Sugar Cookie By Sweet Thing Bake Shop
Classic Sugar Cookie made with love by Sweet Thing Bake Shop.
Mini Cookie And Brownie Tray
Mix of Mini Cookies and Brownie Bites.
Mini Chocolate Chunk M&M Cookie
mini chocolate chunk m&m cookie
Mini Chocolate Chunk M&M Cookie Tray (30 Mini Cookies)
Spaghetti
Includes garlic bread and a side salad.
Mostaccioli
Includes garlic bread and a side salad.
Store Menu - Pastas
Store Menu - Salads
Garden Salad
Iceberg lettuce base with tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, red onions, croutons, and your choice of dressing.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce base with parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing
Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce base with cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, black olives, feta cheese, and Greek dressing
Italian Beef
Italian beef prepared over a 6" loaf of French bread. Includes side of au jus, choice of cheese, choice of toppings and a side of fries or garden salad.
Italian Meatball
Italian meatballs prepared over a 6" loaf of French bread and topped off with red sauce. Includes side of french fries or garden salad.
Grilled Chicken
Boneless chicken breast served on a Brioche bun. Includes side of french fries or garden salad.
Beef Patty
1/3 lb. Ground Beef patty served on a Brioche Bun. Includes side of french fries or garden salad.
Italian Sausage
Italian Sausage prepared over a 6" loaf of French bread. Includes side of au jus, choice of cheese, choice of toppings and a side of fries or garden salad.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Turkey Wrap
Store Menu - Sandwiches, Wraps & Burgers
Store Menu - Crafted Pizza
Double Decker Crust
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with your favorite toppings.
Thin Crust
Made with Tomatoe and Cheese base.
Gluten Free Thin Crust
Made with tomato and cheese base on a gluten-free crust.
Double Decker Judy's Special
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with sausage, mushroom, onions, and green peppers.
Double Decker Veggie
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with spinach, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and tomatoes.
Double Decker Hawaiian
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with canadian bacon and pineapple.
Double Decker Taco
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Chorizo and Cheddar.
Double Decker Greek
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta, & Black Olives.
Double Decker Meat Lovers
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with Sausage, Pepperoni, and Bacon.
Double Decker Chicago
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with double Italian Beef and Hot Giardiniera!
Store Menu - Specialty Pizzas - Double Decker
Store Menu - Specialty Pizzas - Thin Crust
Thin Crust Veggie
Crispy crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with spinach, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and tomatoes.
Thin Crust Hawaiian
Crispy crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with canadian bacon and pineapple.
Thin Crust Judy's Special
Crispy crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, and onions.
Thin Crust Taco
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Chorizo and Cheddar.
Thin Crust Meat Lovers
Sausage, Pepperoni, and Bacon.
Thin Crust Chicago
Double Italian Beef and Hot Giardiniera!
Thin Crust Greek
Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta, & Black Olives
Cheese Slice
Sausage Slice
Pepperoni Slice
Mushroom Slice
Store Menu - Slices
Promotions
Family Meal Deal
Includes 1 Pizza with unlimited toppings, 1 family size salad, and an appetizer platter. Not valid with other promotions.
Lunch Special (2 Slices Drink)
Make Your Own Pizza Kits
Makes two 12" pizzas.
Dino Nugs (6 Piece)
6 Organic Chicken Nuggets (Dinosaur Shaped)
Chicken Noodle
Classic Chicken Noodle. Includes crackers.
Soups
Appetizers
Shoestring Fries
Waffle Fries
Garlic Bread
6" loaf of French bread with a spread of butter, garlic, and parsley
Pizza Bread
Toasted garlic bread layered with sauce and cheese.
Onion Rings
Breaded Zucchinis
Breaded and fried zucchinis. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 10 pieces and a platter includes 20.
Breaded Mushrooms
Breaded and fried mushrooms. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 10 pieces and a platter includes 20.
Jalapeno Poppers
Breaded and battered chili pepper and cheese bites. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 10 pieces and a platter includes 20.
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded and fried cheese. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 5 pieces and a platter includes 10.
Chicken Strips
Breaded and fried chicken strips. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 5 pieces and a platter includes 10.
Chicken Wings
Breaded and fried spicy wings. Comes with your choice of sauce. Side includes 5 pieces and a platter includes 10.
Boneless Chicken Wings
Boneless wings with a spicy kick. Comes with your choice of sauce.
Canned Soda
12oz
Canned Soda - 6 Pack
Gatorade
Gatorade - 6 Pack
Bottled Water
Water Bottle - 6 Pack
20oz Bottle
Apple And Eve Juice Box
Beverages
Desserts
Chocolate Chip Cookie By Sweet Thing Bake Shop
Classic Chocolate Chip homemade with love by Sweet Thing Bake Shop
Classic Brownie By Sweet Thing Bake Shop
Classic brownie homemade with love by Sweet Thing
Sugar Cookie By Sweet Thing Bake Shop
Classic Sugar Cookie made with love by Sweet Thing Bake Shop.
Mini Cookie And Brownie Tray
Mix of Mini Cookies and Brownie Bites.
Mini Chocolate Chunk M&M Cookie
mini chocolate chunk m&m cookie
Mini Chocolate Chunk M&M Cookie Tray (30 Mini Cookies)
Spaghetti
Includes garlic bread and a side salad.
Mostaccioli
Includes garlic bread and a side salad.
Pastas
Salads
Garden Salad
Iceberg lettuce base with tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, red onions, croutons, and your choice of dressing.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce base with parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing
Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce base with cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, black olives, feta cheese, and Greek dressing
Italian Beef
Italian beef prepared over a 6" loaf of French bread. Includes side of au jus, choice of cheese, choice of toppings and a side of fries or garden salad.
Italian Meatball
Italian meatballs prepared over a 6" loaf of French bread and topped off with red sauce. Includes side of french fries or garden salad.
Grilled Chicken
Boneless chicken breast served on a Brioche bun. Includes side of french fries or garden salad.
Beef Patty
1/3 lb. Ground Beef patty served on a Brioche Bun. Includes side of french fries or garden salad.
Italian Sausage
Italian Sausage prepared over a 6" loaf of French bread. Includes side of au jus, choice of cheese, choice of toppings and a side of fries or garden salad.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Turkey Wrap
Sandwiches, Wraps & Burgers
Crafted Pizza
Double Decker Crust
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with your favorite toppings.
Thin Crust
Made with Tomatoe and Cheese base.
Gluten Free Thin Crust
Made with tomato and cheese base on a gluten-free crust.
Double Decker Judy's Special
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with sausage, mushroom, onions, and green peppers.
Double Decker Veggie
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with spinach, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and tomatoes.
Double Decker Hawaiian
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with canadian bacon and pineapple.
Double Decker Taco
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Chorizo and Cheddar.
Double Decker Greek
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta, & Black Olives.
Double Decker Meat Lovers
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with Sausage, Pepperoni, and Bacon.
Double Decker Chicago
Two layers of crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with double Italian Beef and Hot Giardiniera!
Specialty Pizzas - Double Decker
Specialty Pizzas - Thin Crust
Thin Crust Veggie
Crispy crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with spinach, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and tomatoes.
Thin Crust Hawaiian
Crispy crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with canadian bacon and pineapple.
Thin Crust Judy's Special
Crispy crust with a tomato & mozzarella base layered with sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, and onions.
Thin Crust Taco
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Chorizo and Cheddar.
Thin Crust Meat Lovers
Sausage, Pepperoni, and Bacon.
Thin Crust Chicago
Double Italian Beef and Hot Giardiniera!
Thin Crust Greek
Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta, & Black Olives
Cheese Slice
Sausage Slice
Pepperoni Slice
Mushroom Slice
Slices
Catering - Salads - Catering
Garden Salad - Catering
Iceberg lettuce base with tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, red onions, croutons, and your choice of dressing (served on the side). Small serves 12 side servings. Medium serves 18 side servings. Large serves 24 side portions.
Caesar Salad - Catering
Romaine lettuce base with parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing. Pre-mixed for quick serving. Small serves 12 side servings. Medium serves 18 side servings. Large serves 24 side portions.
Greek Salad - Catering
Romaine lettuce base with cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, black olives, and eta cheese. Pre-mixed for quick serving. Small serves 12 side servings. Medium serves 18 side servings. Large serves 24 side portions.
Breaded Mushrooms - Catering
Breaded and fried mushrooms. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 60 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 90 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 120 pieces (24 servings).
Breaded Zucchinis - Catering
Breaded and fried zucchinis. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 60 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 90 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 120 pieces (24 servings).
Jalapeno Poppers - Catering
Breaded and battered chili pepper and cheese bites. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 60 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 90 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 120 pieces (24 servings).
Mozzarella Sticks - Catering
Breaded and fried cheese. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 30 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 45 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 60 pieces (24 servings).
Chicken Strips - Catering
Breaded and fried chicken strips. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 30 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 45 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 60 pieces (24 servings).
Chicken Wings - Catering
Breaded and fried spicy wings. Dressings on side. Small includes about 30 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 45 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 60 pieces (24 servings).
Onion Rings - Catering
Small is about 3lbs (12 servings), Medium is about 4.5 lbs (18 servings), and Large is about 6 lbs (24 servings).
Catering - Appetizers - Catering
Catering - Sandwiches & Wraps Tray - Catering
Italian Beef - Catering
Served a la carte or pre-made. Includes Italian Beef dipped in Au Jus, Mozzarella Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Giardiniera, and toasted French Bread. Pre-made sandwiches include cheese, and sweet peppers with Giardiniera served on the side. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Italian Meatballs - Catering
Served a la carte or pre-made. Includes Italian Meatballs dipped in Marinara sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Giardiniera, and toasted French Bread. Pre-made sandwiches include cheese and sweet peppers with Giardiniera served on the side. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Italian Sausage - Catering
Served a la carte or pre-made. Includes Italian Sausage dipped in Au Jus, Mozzarella Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Giardiniera, and toasted French Bread. Pre-made sandwiches include cheese and sweet peppers with Giardiniera served on the side. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Chicken Caesar Wrap - Catering
Turkey Wrap - Catering
Mixed Wraps - Catering
Spaghetti - Catering
Freshly prepared spaghetti prepared pre-mixed or a la carte. Includes choice of cheese, sauce, and protein (extra). Includes garlic bread. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Mostaccioli - Catering
Freshly prepared penne prepared pre-mixed or a la carte. Includes choice of cheese, sauce, and protein (extra). Includes garlic bread. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Catering - Pasta - Catering
Catering - Boxed Lunches
Boxed Lunches - Personal Pizzas
Boxed Personal Pizzas. Includes kettle chips and a mini cookie.
Boxed Lunches - Individual Salads
Boxed Individual Salads. No customizations. House dressings included. Comes with kettle chips and a mini cookie. Minimum 5 per order.
Boxed Lunches - Individual Pastas
Boxed Personal Pastas. Made with marinara sauce. Includes a side of cheese and garlic bread. Includes an individually packaged mini cookie and a bag of kettle chips which are both served separately. Minimum 5 per order.
Boxed Lunches - Individual Sandwiches
Boxed Personal Sandwiches. Made plain and includes sides of Juice/Sauce, Cheese, Sweet Peppers, & Giardiniera. Includes an individually packaged mini cookie and a bag of kettle chips which are both served separately. Minimum 5 per order.
Utensils (Fork/Spoon/Knife, Napkins, Plates)
Price Per Person. Utensils dependent on ordered items.
Catering Rack - Large
Fits 2 small catering dishes or 1 large catering pan. Includes Catering Rack, Water Pan, and 2 Heating Fuels. Good for 2 hours.
French Fry Tray
Half Pan of French Fries. Serves 12.
Garlic Bread Tray
Half Pan of Garlic Bread. Serves 12.
Fruit Tray
Veggie Tray
Catering - Sides & Misc. Add-ons - Catering
Salads - Catering
Garden Salad - Catering
Iceberg lettuce base with tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, red onions, croutons, and your choice of dressing (served on the side). Small serves 12 side servings. Medium serves 18 side servings. Large serves 24 side portions.
Caesar Salad - Catering
Romaine lettuce base with parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing. Pre-mixed for quick serving. Small serves 12 side servings. Medium serves 18 side servings. Large serves 24 side portions.
Greek Salad - Catering
Romaine lettuce base with cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, black olives, and eta cheese. Pre-mixed for quick serving. Small serves 12 side servings. Medium serves 18 side servings. Large serves 24 side portions.
Breaded Mushrooms - Catering
Breaded and fried mushrooms. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 60 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 90 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 120 pieces (24 servings).
Breaded Zucchinis - Catering
Breaded and fried zucchinis. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 60 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 90 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 120 pieces (24 servings).
Jalapeno Poppers - Catering
Breaded and battered chili pepper and cheese bites. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 60 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 90 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 120 pieces (24 servings).
Mozzarella Sticks - Catering
Breaded and fried cheese. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 30 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 45 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 60 pieces (24 servings).
Chicken Strips - Catering
Breaded and fried chicken strips. Comes with your choice of sauce. Small includes about 30 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 45 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 60 pieces (24 servings).
Chicken Wings - Catering
Breaded and fried spicy wings. Dressings on side. Small includes about 30 pieces (12 servings), Medium includes about 45 pieces (18 servings), and Large includes about 60 pieces (24 servings).
Onion Rings - Catering
Small is about 3lbs (12 servings), Medium is about 4.5 lbs (18 servings), and Large is about 6 lbs (24 servings).
Appetizers - Catering
Sandwiches & Wraps Tray - Catering
Italian Beef - Catering
Served a la carte or pre-made. Includes Italian Beef dipped in Au Jus, Mozzarella Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Giardiniera, and toasted French Bread. Pre-made sandwiches include cheese, and sweet peppers with Giardiniera served on the side. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Italian Meatballs - Catering
Served a la carte or pre-made. Includes Italian Meatballs dipped in Marinara sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Giardiniera, and toasted French Bread. Pre-made sandwiches include cheese and sweet peppers with Giardiniera served on the side. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Italian Sausage - Catering
Served a la carte or pre-made. Includes Italian Sausage dipped in Au Jus, Mozzarella Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Giardiniera, and toasted French Bread. Pre-made sandwiches include cheese and sweet peppers with Giardiniera served on the side. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Chicken Caesar Wrap - Catering
Turkey Wrap - Catering
Mixed Wraps - Catering
Spaghetti - Catering
Freshly prepared spaghetti prepared pre-mixed or a la carte. Includes choice of cheese, sauce, and protein (extra). Includes garlic bread. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Mostaccioli - Catering
Freshly prepared penne prepared pre-mixed or a la carte. Includes choice of cheese, sauce, and protein (extra). Includes garlic bread. Small serves 12 side portions. Medium serves 18 side portions. Large serves 24 side portions.
Pasta - Catering
Boxed Lunches
Boxed Lunches - Personal Pizzas
Boxed Personal Pizzas. Includes kettle chips and a mini cookie.
Boxed Lunches - Individual Salads
Boxed Individual Salads. No customizations. House dressings included. Comes with kettle chips and a mini cookie. Minimum 5 per order.
Boxed Lunches - Individual Pastas
Boxed Personal Pastas. Made with marinara sauce. Includes a side of cheese and garlic bread. Includes an individually packaged mini cookie and a bag of kettle chips which are both served separately. Minimum 5 per order.
Boxed Lunches - Individual Sandwiches
Boxed Personal Sandwiches. Made plain and includes sides of Juice/Sauce, Cheese, Sweet Peppers, & Giardiniera. Includes an individually packaged mini cookie and a bag of kettle chips which are both served separately. Minimum 5 per order.
Utensils (Fork/Spoon/Knife, Napkins, Plates)
Price Per Person. Utensils dependent on ordered items.
Catering Rack - Large
Fits 2 small catering dishes or 1 large catering pan. Includes Catering Rack, Water Pan, and 2 Heating Fuels. Good for 2 hours.
French Fry Tray
Half Pan of French Fries. Serves 12.
Garlic Bread Tray
Half Pan of Garlic Bread. Serves 12.